Dukes, aristocrats and tycoons: Who owns Scotland? – BBC News

Dukes, aristocrats and tycoons: Who owns Scotland? – BBC News


Scotland is renowned for its natural beauty;
breathtaking scenery, vast lochs and glens, and islands that line thousands of miles of
shores. For centuries, entitlement and privilege have
underpinned the country’s rural landscape. And now, some claim the way Scotland’s land
is distributed has become the most unequal in the developed world. Amidst this, a new group of owners have emerged,
along with attempts by the Scottish government to modernise the rules and in turn, encourage
a more diverse ownership pattern. So how does land ownership impact Scotland’s
economy, environment and its people, and does it actually matter who the land belongs to? My name is Malcolm Combe and I’m a senior lecturer at the University of Aberdeen School
of Law. There has been some literature to the effect that Scotland does have the most
concentrated pattern of land ownership in Europe, possibly even the developed world.
This is best reflected in the 432:50 figure that’s most associated with Andy Wightman,
the Green Party MSP. He did some research which suggests that 432 people or entities
own 50% of Scotland’s privately-owned rural land. So that’s excluding, for example,
publicly-owned land, say Ministry of Defence properties and also excluding land in urban
areas. Traditional aristocratic landowners like the
Duke of Buccleuch, still own large swathes of the country. But in recent decades, prospective
owners from abroad have been purchasing slices of land across Scotland.
Take the Danish billionaire Anders Povlsen for example. In 2018, the ASOS majority shareholder
became Scotland’s largest private land owner, after snapping up a whopping 220,000 acres
-that’s roughly twice the size of Barbados. His wealth has allowed him to purchase 12
Highland estates as part of his conservation project called Wildland. And he’s not the only Scandinavian keen on Scotland either. The former CEO of the
LEGO group, Kjeld Kirk Kristiansen, owns several estates, including Ledgowan in Wester Ross. Foreign royalty has been quick to join in on the action also. The billionaire ruler
of Dubai, Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid al-Maktoum owns the 63,000-acre Inverinate estate, which
includes three helipads and a 14-bedroom holiday home. But despite the publicity given to the likes of Sheikh Mohammed and Povlsen, the number
of overseas Scottish landowners is not as big as you might think.
Registers of Scotland figures show that 6% of the titles belong to owners outside Scotland.
The majority of these belong to people living in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, while
just over 1%, or roughly 24,000 titles, are registered to addresses out with the UK. So overseas ownership is not illegal, provided the entity that owns the land is able to trade,
that’s absolutely fine. Is it a problem? A lot of people would say no. Inward investment
is a good thing. But in terms of local accountability, in terms of owners perhaps having a different
set of interests and perceptions to the local community, then perhaps it is seen as a problem
in that regard. With the release of the Panama Papers in 2016,
it has been suggested that 750,000 acres of Scotland is owned in tax havens, potentially
causing challenges for tax authorities and law enforcement.
The actual four recurring derestriction that Registers of Scotland have identified in terms
of offshore ownership are the British Virgin Islands, the Isle of Man, Guernsey and Jersey.
Perhaps that’s tax treatment, perhaps that transparency related, perhaps that’s entirely
arbitrary, but that’s just the way it is. So who takes the crown as the biggest owner
in Scotland? The land is split mainly between public bodies, individuals, communities and
other owners like the Royal Family. But the largest single owner is Forestry and
Land Scotland. They hold 640,000 hectares, the equivalent of thirty-five-times the area
of Glasgow. This land helps boost the economy through logging and tourism.
The Ministry of Defence owns swathes of land across Scotland, some of which is used for
military training exercises. Scotland’s 32 councils own a sizable chunk
too, as do the RSPB and the National Trust. Perhaps more surprising is that the Church
of England makes the list of biggest landowners after buying thousands of hectares of forestry
as part of its investment portfolio. But the overwhelming majority of rural land
is in the hands of private owners – around 57% according to the Scottish government. Land ownership is a hot potato. Like many
other legal systems, Scotland says the right of ownership is the apex right, it is the
right that gives you a really important agenda setting role. The risk would be that you get
a land owner who essentially throws their weight around a little bit. Land can have
such a big impact on other people. If you have a land owner who is particularly thrawn
and stubborn and doesn’t want to do something, then that can have a big impact. This was the case on the Isle of Eigg in the 90s. Islanders previously faced years of issues
with absentee landlords, including the removal of waste from the island. So, they decided
to purchase the land for themselves. £1.5 million pounds was raised and over 20 years
since the buyout, the island’s population has almost doubled. Several pieces of land reform legislation have been passed by the Scottish government.
In 2013, the then-first minister Alex Salmond also set a target of one million acres of
Scotland being owned by local communities by the end of the decade. There was a law passed called the Land Reform Act 2003 which gave communities in rural Scotland
the right to have first dibs on an asset when the land was put up for sale. Then the second
wave of land reform legislation came with the Community Empowerment (Scotland) Act 2015
and that brought in a way for communities to take on a land asset that had been neglected,
abandoned or environmentally mismanaged. The third wave is the most recent Land Reform
(Scotland) Act 2016, which has a right for communities to acquire land when the land
owner has somehow been blocking sustainable development locally. Although the one million acres target is unlikely to be achieved by 2020, the Scottish government
continues to stress that land reform is on a “radical journey”. What is certain is that
the debate over who should own Scotland won’t disappear anytime soon. So land reform is a bit of a recurring issue and this is probably because it’s a bit
of a goldilocks issue. To some, what’s happening at the moment is too hot, to others it’s
too cold, to others it’s just right. So we could imagine returning to these issues
again in the future.

100 Replies to “Dukes, aristocrats and tycoons: Who owns Scotland? – BBC News

  1. It’s strange how there are so many variables between Ireland wales England and Scotland but if we could cherry pick the best parts of all of them the untied kingdom might be for a start united but secondly able to work together

  2. Stop conflicting! The BBC uses government's failure of uniting nations to demonise the relationship between Scotland and England.

    Do not let them fool you.

  3. Coming the day after he failed to buy Greenland, its almost like the BBC is trying to give ideas to Donald Trump!

  4. Hail to the Jacobites. HM Queen Sophie Elizabeth Marie Gabrielle von und zu Liechtenstein is their true ruler.

  5. Scotland belongs to the Scottish people! It's totally obscene that foreigners can own any land there. From an English man by the way.

  6. the taxpayers of the UK own Scotland. Scotlands welfare bill alone is greater than its GDP which is why it will NEVER be independant 🙂

  7. WELCOME TO ILLUMINATI, where all your heart desire are granted and get power over all things in the world, this is well known fact that the illuminati church consist of multi billionaires and have power, weath, riches and be a famous person in the world. Join the illuminati cult online today and get instant sum of 300million dollars with a free home anywhere you choose to live in the world and also get 100,000,000 dollars monthly as a salary… If you are interested please kindly fill the following information’s to this email below ([email protected] or whatsapp the temple;+1{323}319-5738.. BENEFITS GIVEN TO NEW MEMBERS WHO JOIN ILLUMINATI. A Cash Reward of USD $300,000,000 USD A New Sleek Dream CAR valued at USD $120,000 USD A Dream House bought in the country of your own choice One Month holiday (fully paid) to your dream tourist destination. One year Golf Membership package A V.I.P treatment in all Airports in the World A total Lifestyle change Access to Bohemian Grove Monthly payment of $70,000,000 USD into your bank account every month as a member One Month booked Appointment with Top 5 world Leaders and Top 5 Celebrities in the World. Tell us little about yourself… No dirty game,no sacrifices and No evil, a cult of peace, big aim Illuminati email us ([email protected] or call +2348078435485 or whatsapp +2348078435485

  8. we 100% support Scotland people! FREEDOM SCOTLAND!
    we can offer face masks, helmet, umbrella and laser pen for free to Scotland people!
    such a beautiful landscape!

  9. The solution is easy. Elect a legislature that limits any one owner from owning more than 500 acres unless they're operating and living on a working farm. Also, forbid foreign ownership. Additionally, go back and root out ownership through chains of title illegitimately gotten–that includes any land given to nobility, which is inherently illegitimate, or purchased by nobility, whose money is invariably gotten through theft. That's how you start.

  10. 苏格兰人民有权利选择自己国家要走的路,请英国正视人民的诉求,停止肆意打压言论自由,停止使用dc方式暴力殖民苏格兰🦄🦄

  11. Where is the voice from Aberdeen? Where is the AUOB? Why British presses reported foreign news all day long but ignored the voice from their own natives. Is that a kind of British sense of free press or a kind of British sense of joke? I don’t get it.

  12. The long term land reform Scotland (and other countries) should pass, is the 'Freedom to Roam' laws on the Scandinavian model.

  13. The obvious question is – how can 4.5 billion-year-old land, be owned ?
    BBC – making the impossible, seem normal. Enjoy the show.

  14. Scottish independence now …the rest of the UK cant stand the fried bar chomping bunch of racist alkies and druggies.

  15. Say it with me I want all 500 replys

    BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS BBC IS FAKE NEWS

  16. Bloody Briton pigs🐷 free Scotland… Then sing your national anthem "GOD FUCK THE QUEEN" or whatever shit that is..
    🇬🇧🖕

  17. History Shows Natural Migration
    Europeans Pilgrims Need To See Greenland Opportunity Now
    Future Insight ! Cheers

  18. Maybe Scotland gives land to the scotsmen that setup plantations in Ireland? Small print reads "free land when you return Irish land to Ireland".

  19. When I roam around the lochs, hills and glens, and along the coast of Scotland – it feels like I own Scotland!

  20. When we were very young, we Chinese knew that Scotland had a great hero. His name was William Wallace. He sacrificed for the freedom of Scotland. Now England still oppresses the Scottish people, discriminates against their accent and culture, plunders the oil of the Scottish people, and completely disregards the wishes of the Scottish people. Now is the time to tell the incompetent British government that the Scottish people want to stay in the EU and that you have nothing to do with Scotland. Blessings from China

  21. I thought that William Wallace fought a successful revolution against England. It was my understanding that Robert the Bruce then took the Crown and promptly made land deals with England for powerful Scottish clans and power in England. I guess those deals still stand today. Not too much trickle down in Scotland.

  22. The UK Owns Scotland Weather They Like It Or Not Its Part of The UK We Are Stronger Together! Its Mad To Think They Can Be Better On There Own When The UK Has Protected Scotland For 300 Years! No One Will Fuck With You Because The UK Will Defend The Land! United Kingdom Has The power In The World Because We Are United! If This was To Ever Change The Country Would Fall Apart And Never Have The Same Power In World Again Because we Would Be Too Small And Divided For Any One To Care We Want The World To Take The UK As A Country To Respect And Fear That is How You Get Shit Done! Long Live The United Kingdom!

  23. HMMMMMM !!!!!!   GIVE SCOTLAND BACK TO THEM       !!!!!!!!!!!!!GIVE  IRELAND —–  BACK TO THEM TOO    !!!!GIVE WALES ———  BACK TO THEM AS WELL    !!!!READ THEIR INDIVIDUAL HISTORIES    !!!!SO DOES NOT BELONG TO THE E.U.    !!!ENGLAND NEEDS TO NEOGCIATE   THERE ARE ON THEIR OWN     !!!!!!!!!!FROM (U.K.).

  24. Scotland is free you can not sell what you do not own so all the land belong's to the people of Scotland..anything else is a lie.

  25. The BBC is as corrupt as the EU and always sell's us fake news..Scotland . England. Wales N .Ireland must unite but have each other's own independence and free from a corrupt EU.

  26. @BBC News
    So; how many of those people own land in Fee Simple? How many of those, so called land owners, have Armorial Bearings? Im gonna be home soon. This nonsense is gonna stop immediately!!!

  27. The Scottish people own Scotland.
    Scotland is the world leader in sectarian gang wars, match day domestic violence and traditional kebab shop stabbings.
    Let's not lose our national identity.

  28. Who owns England? It's a ridiculous question.
    Yet the BBC asks who owns Scotland?
    The Scottish people off course you bloody idiots.

  29. Mother Earth and father time!. That's who owns Scotland. You think you own property anywhere? You're just another idiot that signed a piece of paper. It ain't going to mean Jack when everything's burned down and washed away by Mother Earth and father time. Have fun with that?. It's the truth! I don't care how much property or wealth you own everyone rents on Mother Earth on borrowed father X credit!. Suckers!.

  30. SELL SCOTTLAND to trump he’s been looking for some new Real estate recently . and I’m sure he’ll make money out of the place unlike the Scottish who still rely on the English for their existence THE SHAME OF IT ALL 😩

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *